Permission to reprint this case has been granted by Captus Press Inc. and the Accounting Education Resource Centre of the University of Lethbridge. Foster’s Construction Ltd: Organizational Background Fosters Construction Ltd (FCL) is a privately owned company with revenue of £20 million per annum, and 200 employees. The company has been operating for 24 years and is well established in the market-place. However, despite a national rate of 4 per cent per annum over the last few years (which is expected to continue), a general economic downturn has seen FCL’s nominal revenue reduce at a rate of about 3 per cent per annum. The company’s main activity is the construction of large industrial buildings. It also provides maintenance services, mainly for those buildings which it has constructed. FCL has a large investment in construction machinery, and has always kept up with the latest technology in the industry. The company has concentrated on developing a corporate image as an innovative, technologically advanced construction firm, and many of the managers of FCL consider that this corporate image has been a major factor in securing large, competitive contracts in the past. FCL is subject to corporation tax at 35 per cent, payable twelve months after year end, and a system of 25 per cent writing down allowance on capital assets. FCL’s Formal Capital Investment System An investment in construction equipment is central to the operations of FCL, the organization has, over many years, developed a detailed system by which capital investment proposals are considered. The summary sheet in Exhibit 1 is taken from the firm’s capital investment procedures manual, and outlines the formal process for capital investment decision-making within FCL. The Current CI Decision: Purchase of a Replacement Crane The construction site manager (CSM) has recently submitted a CI/12 application for the purchase of a new crane. The new asset would replace an existing crane which is ten years old, and which requires major maintenance in order to meet required safety standards. The CSM has indicated in the January budget-setting around that the firm would need to spend money maintaining the old crane, but had not at that stage been aware of any replacement options. It had previously been expected that the existing crane would see out its remaining useful life, to be replaced by a more modern crane (the Auto-Lift II, or ‘AL II’). The AL II is technologically more advanced than the firm’s existing crane, and is able to lift much larger loads. The new crane would cost £345 000, which is considerably more than the original £195 000 cost of the existing crane. The CSM consulted with the site accountants, and put forward the following information in the CI/12 application: 1. Description: purchase of an AL II crane to replace an existing crane which is in need of major maintenance. 2. Cost projections: purchase price = £345 000; annual running cost = £60 000. It is expected that the AL II crane would have a £30 000 scrap value at the end of its useful life in ten years’ time. 3. Projected time-scale; available for purchase from Allied Importers Ltd in one month’s time. Purchase price payable on 31 March – the last day of FCL’s financial year for taxation purposes. The site accountants and the CSM had agreed that no further information was necessary, as the CI proposal qualified as a ‘replacement of existing asset’ Class I investment. The CSM’s CI/12 application has now been considered by the director of CI, who feels uneasy about recommending the AL II crane purchase for funding approval. The director of CI has called a meeting of concerned parties to discuss the CI application. EXHIBIT 1 Fosters Construction Ltd Capital Investment Procedures – Summary Capital investment (CI) is defined as ‘any major expenditure on purchasing, construction or upgrading capital assets, the benefits from which will accrue over several years. 1. In early January of each year the CI budget is determined. The total amount of available funds for CI expenditure is determined by the directors, based on what they consider the company can afford. 2. Later that month, divisional managers meet to discuss forthcoming CI requirements, and the budget allocated across divisions. Managers must present their proposed CI requirements under the following three headings: (i). essential replacement of existing assets (Class 1); (ii). strategic expansion (Class 2); (iii). safety and regulatory expenditure (Class 3). The final allocation across divisions is a decision taken jointly by the CEO and the director of CI. 3. Throughout the year, access to funds for investment requires the submission of a standard form CI/12 – Capital Expenditure Application. The information normally required with such as submission includes: (i). a description of the proposed investment; (ii). motivation for the investment, i.e. what will the investment achieve for the company; (iii). financial projections of the cost of the investment; (iv). projected future financial benefits of the investment; (v). key success indicators for the investment (used for assessing the riskiness of the project and for subsequent post audit); (vi). a projected time-scale for completion of the investment. However, proposed Class 3 projects may dispense with items (iv) and (v), and those in Class 1 may dispense with items (ii), (iv) and (v). 4. The CI/12 form is assessed by the director of CI, who has the following options: (i). accept the proposal and forward it to the CEO for financing approval; (ii). refer the proposal back for further refinement; (iii). reject the proposal. CI proposals will be assessed with regard to the net present value (NPV) and payback period (PP) of the proposed project, although Class I projects will be considered as ‘cost minimization exercises’, since there is already an accepted need to continue with current operations and assets, and Class 3 projects are not required to meet financial criteria. 5. All CI projects are assessed within a ten-year planning horizon, i.e. investment effects beyond this ten-year horizon are considered uncertain, and are ignored. 6. If approved, a CI proposal is then allocated funds from the annual budget. A project supervisor is then assigned, and this person is responsible for the implementation and reporting of the CI project. 7. In due course, some selected CI projects will be subject to post audit by the director of CI. The Meeting Participants The following people are present at the meeting to discuss the AL II purchase proposal; • Sonya Carson (SC) Director of CI. Sonya is new to this position, and is familiarizing herself with the technical nature of the firm’s operations. She has an undergraduate economics degree and is considered competent, if perhaps a little over-ambition. However, many longer-serving organizational members doubt Sonya’s ability to make good decisions regarding investment in an industry about which she currently knows little. For this reason, her appointment to the position of Director of CI was controversial. • Julian Done (JD) Construction Site Manager (CSM). Julian has worked in the construction industry for 15 years, progressing through the ranks to become CSM two years ago. He is considered to be competent in his job, but is perceived as uncompromising and confrontational. Julian has no time for ‘the head office bosses’, and his outspoken manner at meetings has often met with disapproval from the CEO. • Franc Silvero (FS) CEO of Foster’s Construction Ltd. Franc came to FCL seven years ago when the construction industry was in a boom period. Received much accolade for record sales levels when he first joined the firm as Contracts Director, and so has continued to implement the policies which had met with success in the past. Franc is now perceived as conservative, and often resists movement towards new areas of business operations. He has a construction background, and sometimes feels uncomfortable with his new managerial role as CEO. • Henry Morton (HM) Engineering Manager. Henry has an engineering degree and has worked in the trade for eight years, joining FCL three years ago. Henry is often called to give advice on the technical and operating implications of capital asset purchases, as well as their probable maintenance costs. Henry keeps up-to-date on innovation and new technology in the construction industry, and in his opinion is well respected. However, Henry has is the past been frustrated in several attempts to introduce advanced technology into FCL’s construction equipment, and blames this on the conservative approach of Franc Silvero. The Meeting The meeting called by Sonya turned out to lengthy and lively. The was a considerable debate, and the following excerpt reflects the main comments raised by the participants. SC: Look Julian, there just isn’t enough information here. I have to be able to work out the new crane’s NPV and payback period. In the past, if projects haven’t had a positive NPV at a required rate of return of 26 per cent, and paid back within five years, then they haven’t been approved. Do we know anything about the financial benefits which the AL II might produce? What advantage is there in buying this thing now? Couldn’t we just let our old crane run its course and consider our options once it reaches the end of its useful life in a few years' time? FS: Yes, I think we need to look more closely at the details here. Julian, what do you think the outlook is if we stay with the old crane? JD: The old crane really needs some maintenance work done on it, to bring it up to safety standards. If we spent about £40 000 on maintenance straight away it should be OK until it goes out of commission in five years’ time. FS: What does it cost to run the old crane? JD: Running costs are around £40 000 per annum. Plus, the crane’s getting unreliable. I reckon there’s about a 50 per cent chance that it will break down at some time during the year. If it does we lose three days' productivity on a job at a cost of around £15 000, not to mention the cost of fixing it, which was £10 000 last time. Even once it’s fixed there’s still a 50 per cent chance it could break down again within the next twelve months. FS: What if we go for the AL II? JD: The running costs would be a bit higher, as it’s a finely tuned machine and needs regular maintenance. I reckon we’re looking at about £60 000 a year, judging by the recommended service programme. But, at least it’s not likely to break down. Also, I’m sure that the AL II would improve our chances of winning contracts – it’s faster and it will help keep costs down. Take for example that Storex contract we missed out on last month. The kind of cost savings we could get with the AL II could have won us that bid, and jobs like that are worth around £40 000 pre-tax profit to FCL. We could pick up a couple more like that one each year – maybe more. FS: How would you rate the chance of picking up more work with the AL II? JD: Well, probably about 60 per cent chance that we’d get another two like the Storex job each year, and perhaps about 20 per cent chance of doubling that. It’s hard to say really, but the customers out there are feeling the pinch – we’ve got to watch our cost competitiveness if we want to stay in the game. HM: That’s a key point here, I think. We’ve got to take a long-term view. The way I read it, these AL II cranes will take over the market in the next two years, and by the time we came to replace the old crane five years from now, we’d be looking at buying an AL II anyway. The question is, do we get in on the new technology now, or in five years' time? We really can’t assume that the status quo will continue if we don’t go for the AL II now. We’re looking at a fall in price competitiveness, company image and profits if we don’t move with the times. If we do go with the AL II now, we’ve got an edge over our competitors. Even then, we wouldn’t want to hang on to the AL II for more than ten years – we need to keep upgrading to keep ahead of the game. JD: I can’t see what the problem is with these numbers Sonya has to crunch. It’s only an asset replacement, and I’ve given you all the information the manual says you need. Besides, I told everyone in January that we’d need to spend some money on the crane, so we all knew this was coming. FS: That’s true, Julian, but we’re talking £345 000 now, whereas we only expected to spend £40 000 on maintenance. I’m not at all sure that we want to get into experimental technology anyway, it seems pretty risky. What’s wrong with maintaining the old crane, as planned? It’s still got five years left in it, and they’re pretty hard to sell second-hand. It’s in our books at £10 981 after accumulated WDAs. We’d probably only get about £20 000 for it if we want to sell it, which isn’t much more than the £5000 scrap value we’d get for it in five years’ time. SC: Julian, perhaps you, Henry and I can sit down and draw up the figures, including the cost and benefit information you’ve mentioned today. Then I can run the numbers and see if it meets our investment criteria. There’s just a couple of things that bother me, though. It doesn’t seem right to use the same required rate of return for every project. We should be using different rates for different types of projects. I’ve been playing around with a few numbers, and it seems to me that 26 per cent is too high. It might be OK for risky projects that are something new to us, but here we’re talking about a crane. That’s run-of-the-mill stuff for FCL, and it seems to me that a 21 per cent nominal required return would be more appropriate. Also, looking at past records of CI analyses, it looks like the 26 per cent rate has been used as a real discount rate, when it is actually calculated to represent a nominal rate. We really need to do some inflation adjustments to the rates we’re using. JD: This is all gobbledegook to me. Perhaps that’s the problem here – we’re so tied up in the numbers that we can’t see a good investment when it hits us in the face! FS: We have to be sure that any investment is financially viable, Julian. Sonya, why don’t you run the numbers both ways: the way we have in the past, and again using a rate you think is appropriate. I’d be interested in seeing what difference it makes, although there’s never been a shortage of projects in the past that have made the 26 per cent grade. I hope you wouldn’t be cutting it too fine using a rate like 21 per cent. It doesn’t seem to leave much margin for error if our project estimates turn out to be wrong. SC: I’ll run the numbers, but the best way of dealing with margins for error is by getting things right in the first place. There’s still a lot of uncertainty on this project. All we’ve got so far are ‘feelings’ and estimates – do you think we can firm up those figures at all? JD: No. There just isn’t any other information. Look, I’ve been in this industry since before you finished school – I’ve learnt enough to know what’s what. I can tell you now that sooner or later we’ll need a new crane to be able to do our jobs, and doing our jobs is what makes money for this company! FS: OK, Julian, no one’s doubting your judgement. Sonya, how about doing what you suggested, and sitting down with Henry and Julian. They should be able to give you the technical information, and you can work through the numbers. I’d like to see the IRR too – I’ve never been able to understand why we don’t calculate IRR. I know a lot of other firms that do. HM: Maybe we could think about changing the CI procedures manual too. That way, the technical people will know exactly what information the director of CI needs and things can be settled faster. SC: Fine, that’s a good idea. Look, I know we haven’t resolved this, but thanks for coming to this meeting. Perhaps we can all get together again in a week’s time to make a decision. Discussion Questions: 1. Present the financial analyses required by FCL’s CI procedures manual, as they have traditionally been calculated. Explain any assumptions you make. According to FCL’s usual decision criteria, would the AL II be purchased now? 2. Explain to JD the difference between real and nominal RRRs, as mentioned by SC. What adjustment to SC’s suggested RRR would be needed in order to match the discount rate with the cashflows used? 3. Re-calculate the NPV of the AL II purchase proposal, using what Sonya Carson would consider to be an appropriate RRR. Do these revised NPV results suggest that the AL II should be purchased? 4. In the light of your calculations for the AL II purchase proposal, what would be your response to FS’s comment that the IRR of projects should be calculated? 5. What do you think might be the key variables in the AL II investment which will affect its viability? How might you consider these uncertain variables in better assessing the proposal? 6. What further information would be useful in analysing the AL II proposal? 7. Identify any problems that you see regarding the following: (a). the current CI procedures manual (as outlined in the summary) (b). communication and consultation between the people involved in, and affected by, the CI decision. 8. Do you consider that it would be wise to conduct a post audit if this asset were purchased, to see if it is achieving the expected benefits? It so, how might you use the findings of such a post audit? 9. Suggest changes to FCL’s CI procedures which might improve future CI decision-making.
> Consider the data of Review Exercise 13.45 on page 555. Make significance tests on the following contrasts: (a) B versus A, C, and D; (b) C versus A and D; (c) A versus D. Exercise 13.45: Four laboratories are being used to perform chemical analysis. Sa
> Use Bartlett’s test at the 0.05 level of significance to test for homogeneity of variances in Exercise 13.6 on page 519. Exercise 13.6: A study measured the sorption (either absorption or adsorption) rates of three different types of o
> A random variable X follows a negative binomial distribution with parameters k = 5 and p [i.e.,b ∗ (x; 5, p)]. Furthermore, we know that p follows a uniform distribution on the interval (0, 1). Find the Bayes estimate of p under the squared-error loss fu
> Use Cochran’s test at the 0.01 level of significance to test for homogeneity of variances in Exercise 13.4 on page 519. Exercise 13.4: Immobilization of free-ranging white-tailed deer by drugs allows researchers the opportunity to clos
> Six different machines are being considered for use in manufacturing rubber seals. The machines are being compared with respect to tensile strength of the product. A random sample of four seals from each machine is used to determine whether the mean tens
> (a) Fit a multiple regression equation of the form μY |x = β0 + β1x + β2x2 to the data of Example 11.8 on page 420. (b) Estimate the yield of the chemical reaction for a temperature of 225 ◦ C.
> The following is a set of coded experimental data on the compressive strength of a particular alloy at various values of the concentration of some additive: (a) Estimate the quadratic regression equation μY |x = β0 + Î&s
> An experiment was conducted in order to determine if cerebral blood flow in human beings can be predicted from arterial oxygen tension (millimeters of mercury). Fifteen patients participated in the study, and the following data were collected: Estimat
> An experiment was conducted on a new model of a particular make of automobile to determine the stopping distance at various speeds. The following data were recorded. (a) Fit a multiple regression curve of the form μD|v = β0 +
> Rayon whiteness is an important factor for scientists dealing in fabric quality. Whiteness is affected by pulp quality and other processing variables. Some of the variables include acid bath temperature, â—¦ C (x1); cascade acid concent
> A client from the Department of Mechanical Engineering approached the Consulting Center at Virginia Tech for help in analyzing an experiment dealing with gas turbine engines. The voltage output of engines was measured at various combinations of blade spe
> For the quadratic model of Exercise 12.51(b), give estimates of the variances and covariances of the estimates of β1 and β11. Exercise 12.51(b): The following is a set of data for y, the amount of money (in thousands of dollars)
> For the model of Exercise 12.50(a), test the hypothesis H0: β4 = 0, H1: β4 ≠0. Use a P-value in your conclusion. Exercise 12.50(a): For the punter data in Case Study 12.2, an additional response, â€
> Suppose that a sample consisting of 5, 6, 6, 7, 5, 6, 4, 9, 3, and 6 comes from a Poisson population with mean λ. Assume that the parameter λ follows a gamma distribution with parameters (3, 2). Under the squared-error loss function, find the Bayes estim
> The following is a set of data for y, the amount of money (in thousands of dollars) contributed to the alumni association at Virginia Tech by the Class of 1960, and x, the number of years following graduation: (a) Fit a regression model of the type &Ici
> For the punter data in Case Study 12.2, an additional response, “punting distance,” was also recorded. The average distance values for each of the 13 punters are given. (a) Using the distance data rather than the hang
> The electric power consumed each month by a chemical plant is thought to be related to the average ambient temperature x1, the number of days in the month x2, the average product purity x3, and the tons of product produced x4. The past yearâ€&
> Use the techniques of backward elimination with α = 0.05 to choose a prediction equation for the data of Table 12.8.
> For the data of Exercise 12.15 on page 452, use the techniques of (a) forward selection with a 0.05 level of significance to choose a linear regression model; (b) backward elimination with a 0.05 level of significance to choose a linear regression mode
> Consider the “hang time” punting data given in Case Study 12.2, using only the variables x2 and x3. (a) Verify the regression equation shown on page 489. (b) Predict punter hang time for a punter with LLS = 180 pounds and Power = 260 foot-pounds. (c) C
> A study was done to determine whether the gender of the credit card holder was an important factor in generating profit for a certain credit card company. The variables considered were income, the number of family members, and the gender of the card hold
> A study was done to assess the cost effectiveness of driving a four-door sedan instead of a van or an SUV (sports utility vehicle). The continuous variables are odometer reading and octane of the gasoline used. The response variable is miles per gallon.
> For the data set given in Exericise 12.16 on page 453, can the response be explained adequately by any two regressor variables? Discuss. Exericise 12.16: An engineer at a semiconductor company wants to model the relationship between the gain or hFE of a
> Consider the data of Exercise 12.13 on page 452. Can the response, wear, be explained adequately by a single variable (either viscosity or load) in an SLR rather than with the full two-variable regression? Justify your answer thoroughly through tests of
> Suppose that the time to failure T of a certain hinge is an exponential random variable with probability density f(t) = θe−θt, t>0. From prior experience we are led to believe that θ is a value
> In Example 12.8, a case is made for eliminating x1, powder temperature, from the model since the P-value based on the F-test is 0.2156 while P-values for x2 and x3 are near zero. (a) Reduce the model by eliminating x1, thereby producing a full and a rest
> Consider Example 12.3 on page 447. Compare the two competing models. First order: yi = β0 + β1x1i + β2x2i + €i, Second order: yi = β0 + β1x1i + β2x2i+ β11x21i + β22x22i + β12x1ix2i + i. Use R2adj in your comparison. Test H0 : β11 = β22 =β12 = 0. In addit
> Consider Example 12.4. Figure 12.1 on page 459 displays a SAS printout of an analysis of the model containing variables x1, x2, and x3. Focus on the confidence interval of the mean response μY at the (x1, x2, x3) locations representing the 13 data points
> An experiment was conducted to determine if the weight of an animal can be predicted after a given period of time on the basis of the initial weight of the animal and the amount of feed that was eaten. The following data, measured in kilograms, were reco
> Consider the data of Exercise 11.55 on page 437. Fit a regression model using weight and drive ratio as explanatory variables. Compare this model with the SLR (simple linear regression) model using weight alone. Use R2, R2adj, and any t-statistics (or F-
> Consider the data for Exercise 12.36. Compute the following: R(β1 | β0), R(β1 | β0, β2, β3), R(β2 | β0, β1), R(β2 | β0, &I
> Consider the electric power data of Exercise 12.5 on page 450. Test H0: β1 = β2 = 0, making use of R(β1, β2 | β3, β4). Give a P-value, and draw conclusions. Exercise 12.5: The elec
> A small experiment was conducted to fit a multiple regression equation relating the yield y to temperature x1, reaction time x2, and concentration of one of the reactants x3. Two levels of each variable were chosen, and measurements corresponding to the
> Repeat Exercise 12.17 on page 461 using an F-statistic. Exercise 12.17: For the data of Exercise 12.2 on page 450, estimate σ2. Exercise 12.2: In Applied Spectroscopy, the infrared reflectance spectra properties of a viscous liquid used in
> For the model of Exercise 12.5 on page 450, test the hypothesis H0: β1 = β2 = 0, H1: β1 and β2 are not both zero. Exercise 12.5: The electric power consumed each month by a chemical plant is thought to be
> Suppose that in Example 18.7 the electrical firm does not have enough prior information regarding the population mean length of life to be able to assume a normal distribution for μ. The firm believes, however, that μ is surel
> Estimate the proportion of defectives being produced by the machine in Example 18.1 if the random sample of size 2 yields 2 defectives.
> This is an extract from Ducker, H., Head, A., McDonnell, B., O’Brien, R. and Richardson, S. (1998), A Creative Approach to Management Accounting: Case Studies in Management Accounting and Control, Sheffield Hallam University Press, ISBN
> This case study is taken from Ducker, J., Head, A., McDonnell, B., O'Brien, R. and Richardson, S. (1998), A Creative Approach to Management Accounting: Case Studies in Management Accounting and Control, Sheffield Hallam University Press, ISBN 086339 791
> Southern Paper Inc. is a global packaging company headquartered in the United States. The company was founded in the 1880s and has three principal business sectors – forest products, packaging and papers. The forest products division supplies lumber to t
> This case study is taken from Ducker, J., Head, A., McDonnell, B., O'Brien, R. and Richardson, S. (1998), A Creative Approach to Management Accounting: Case Studies in Management Accounting and Control, Sheffield Hallam University Press, ISBN 086339 791
> This case was originally set in the 1960s in rural Vermont. The Majestic Lodge is an old but well-maintained property that has changed ownership several times over the years. It has no restaurant or bar. It is positioned as a mid-price, good quality "des
> The Managing Director of the Kiddy Toy Company (KTC) needs to decide whether a special export order should be accepted or rejected, with reasons provided, for the manufacture of Panda bears. The background Official statistics indicate that China manufact
> Professor Anthony Atkinson, (University of Waterloo) and adapted by Professor John Shank (The Amos Tuck School of Business Administration Dartmouth College) This case is reprinted from Cases in Cost Management, Shank, J. K., 1996, South Western Publishin
> Anjo Ltd was established in 1986 by two brothers, Andrew and Jonathan Bright. They saw a market for providing accessories in the home to accommodate the new era of home entertainment, such as television cabinets, record stands, hi-fi cabinets, tape casse
> Airport Complex was founded in Northern Europe in the early 1960s, and at the time it primarily served as a domestic airport. During the 1980s, flights to foreign destinations became an ever more vital activity for the airport. Today, the airport functio
> Hardhat Ltd’s Budget Committee, which has members drawn from all the major functions in the business, is meeting to consider the projected income statement for 2018/2019, which is composed of the ten months’ actuals to
> The Application of Linear Programming to Management Accounting Midland Airport Ltd LEARNING OBJECTIVES: After reading this case study and completing the questions you will be able to: • Formulate the initial linear programming model (ob
> Fleet operates a chain of high street retail outlets selling clothing and household items. In 1995 this company was heading for a financial loss and was deemed to have lost strategic direction. The business formula that had proved successful in the 1980s
> This case study is taken from Ducker, J., Head, A., McDonnell, B., O'Brien, R. and Richardson, S. (1998), A Creative Approach to Management Accounting: Case Studies in Management Accounting and Control, Sheffield Hallam University Press, ISBN 086339 791
> In November 2012, a consultant was employed to review and document the planning and control systems of Integrated Technology Services (UK) Ltd (ITS-UK), to ensure that these were effectively meeting the needs of the business and to provide a basis for st
> This case was originally set in a specialty manufacturer of industrial measuring instruments in Scotland in 1979. The topic is profit variance analysis. THE FIRM Kinkead has been a leading UK firm since World War II in specialty instruments for measuring
> Company A is in the chemical industry and a manufacturer of industrial paints. At one of its manufacturing sites (site 1) a new system of costing and management information is being considered to replace a traditional system, which was not meeting fully
> The Board of Dumbellow Ltd are meeting on the 23rd January to discuss the draft budget for 2018/19, some two months before the start of that year. The company produces three industrial valves which are incorporated into equipment used in the Oil and Gas
> Learning objectives: After reading this case study and completing the questions you will be able to: • Demonstrate familiarity with two methods of process costing: weighted average and FIFO. • Discuss the treatment of normal loss, abnormal loss and abnor
> The case was prepared as the basis for discussion rather than to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of an administrative situation. Danfoss Drives A/S is a Danish producer of frequency converters located in Graasten in the southern part
> Company B is a manufacturer of large, complex electrical motors. It has been making them 'to order', in order quantities of, typically, one-four in a jobbing/batch production system for many years. A typical selling price may range from £3000-£20 000 per
> Learning objectives: After reading this case study and completing the questions you will be able to: • Explain the alternative methods of allocating joint costs to products. • Discuss the arguments for and against each
> Mestral is a highly successful company manufacturing a range of quality bathroom fittings. For the past 15 years production has been carried out at three locations: Northern town in the North East of England; at Western town on the Severn estuary; and at
> Kaminsky Ltd manufactures belts and braces. The firm is organized into five departments. These are belt-making, braces-making and three service departments (maintenance, warehousing and administration). Direct costs are accumulated for each department. F
> (a). Flopro plc makes and sells two products A and B, each of which passes through the same automated production operations. The following estimated information is available for period 1: (ii). Production/sales of products A and B are 120 000 units and
> Galuppi plc is considering whether to scrap some highly specialized old plant or to refurbish it for the production of drive mechanisms, sales of which will last for only three years. Scrapping the plant will yield £25 000 immediately, where
> Franzl is a contract engineer working for a division of a large construction company. He is responsible for the negotiation of contract prices and the subsequent collection of instalment monies from customers. It is company policy to achieve a mark-up of
> Paragon Products plc has a factory that manufactures a wide range of plastic household utensils. One of these is a plastic brush that is made from a special raw material used only for this purpose. The brush is moulded on a purpose-built machine that was
> Losrock Housing Association is considering the implementation of a refurbishment programme on one of its housing estates which would reduce maintenance and heating costs and enable a rent increase to be made. Relevant data are as follows: (i). Number of
> Using the discounted cash flow yield (internal rate of return) for evaluating investment opportunities has the basic weakness that it does not give attention to the amount of the capital investment, in that a return of 20 per cent on an investment of &Ac
> The Portsmere Hospital operates its own laundry. Last year the laundry processed 120 000 kilograms of washing and this year the total is forecast to grow to 132 000 kilograms. This growth in laundry processed is forecast to continue at the same percentag
> You are employed as the assistant accountant in your company and you are currently working on an appraisal of a project to purchase a new machine. The machine will cost £55 000 and will have a useful life of three years. You have already est
> Your company is considering investing in its own transport fleet. The present position is that carriage is contracted to an outside organization. The life of the transport fleet would be five years, after which time the vehicles would have to be disposed
> Garrett Automative Ltd (GAL) is a UK subsidiary of a American parent company that manufactures turbochargers for the automative industry. GAL decided to begin its profit improvement programme by examining its factory throughput. Throughput was defined as
> The following information relates to three possible capital expenditure projects. Because of capital rationing only one project can be accepted: The company estimates its cost of capital is 18 per cent. Calculate: (a). The payback period for each proje
> Short flower Ltd currently publish, print and distribute a range of catalogues and instruction manuals. The management has now decided to discontinue printing and distribution and concentrate solely on publishing. Long plant Ltd will print and distribute
> Cassidy Computers plc sells one of its products, a plug-in card for personal computer systems, in both the UK and Ruritania. The relationship between price and demand is different in the two markets, and can be represented as follows: Home market: Price
> Butterfield Ltd manufactures a single brand of dog food called ‘Lots O Grissle’ (LOG). Sales have stabilized for several years at a level of £20 million per annum at current prices. This level is not expected to change in the foreseeable future (except a
> Safety or buffer stocks are held for many reasons. For example, road authorities might want to hold sufficient stock of grit salt in case of bad weather, or firms might build stock of key materials if a price rise is impending. In recent times climate c
> The Boeing 737 jet is the world’s most popular and reliable commercial airliner. The company has manufactured over 8000 jets in the 737 family. In 2005, the 737-900ER was launched, which can carry more passengers over a further range than any previous mo
> Modern day aircraft are complex pieces of engineering, increasingly using more technology, composite materials and more efficient engines. Aircraft engines are in particular improving not only in fuel efficiency, but also in range, thus contributing to l
> South African energy and chemicals company Sasol, like many companies dealing with large-scale projects, needs to prepare cost estimates. Sasol specialize in high value liquid fuels, chemicals and low-carbon electricity. In 2014, the company decided to i
> In the March 2012 edition of CIMA’s Financial Management journal, Christian Doherty asks what will management accountants ten years on be grappling with? This question has been posed before (see, for example, Scapings et al., 2003) and technology is a fa
> According to a US Congressional enquiry, this accident apparently partly resulted from local decisions within the oil multinational BP and its contractors to save relatively immaterial costs by cutting corners in oil exploration safety measures (National
> As one of the pioneers in the low-cost airline market, easyJet’s business model includes some core values: ● Safety – Our number one value, sitting at the core of everything we do. ● Pioneering – We challenge to find new ways to make travel easy and affo
> Insteel Industries decided to implement ABM at the Andrews, South Carolina, plant. The ABM team analysed operations and identified 12 business processes involving a total of 146 activities. The ABM study revealed that the 20 most expensive activities acc
> Taylor, Woods and Cheng Ge Fang (2014) reported on how one UK company moved its target costing system away from profit targets and focused it on product-level economic value added (EVA(TM)) targets. The company, which used the pseudonym Electronics for c
> Management accounting combines accounting, finance and management with the leading-edge techniques needed to drive successful businesses. Chartered management accountants: ● Advise managers about the financial implications of projects. ● Explain the fina
> Following events of September 2001, airport security screening in the US and globally increased dramatically. As we all know, this led to increasing queues at airports which while inconvenient, are paramount to the safety and security of passengers. Sin
> As a result of the recent financial troubles at Tesco its shares declined to an 11-year low in 2014. Terry Smith, chief executive of investment house Fundsmith, stated in an article published in The Financial Times that investors had long ignored warning
> An article by Chen et al. (2015) published in Strategic Finance described how Zhongyuan Special Steel Co. (ZYSCO), a typical Chinese state-owned company, introduced a new strategic management system that would integrate its value creation strategy into e
> Southwest Airlines set ‘operating efficiency’ as its strategic theme. The four perspectives embodied in the balanced scorecard were linked together by a series of relatively simple questions and answers: Financial: Wha
> The Globe and Mail (Canada) quotes an article written by Professor Pietro Micheli in Industry Week in which he listed seven myths about performance management that promote the wrong behaviours. The following is a summary of these myths: Myth 1: Numbers
> Across Europe, just how much – or little – US multinational firms are paying in taxes is coming under intense scrutiny according to an article published in the Washington Post. Most of the investigations revolve around the issue of ‘transfer pricing’, wh
> According to an article in the Financial Times the UK tax authority (HMRC – HM Revenue & Customs) raised £1.1bn from challenging the pricing of multinational companies’ internal deals in 2013–14 – more than twice as much as in the previous year. The incr
> Medical devices are normally associated with use by hospitals and medical practices. Some devices are used by normal consumers and, according to an article on the Medical Device and Diagnostic Industry website (www.mddionline.com), are proliferating. The
> Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd reorganized its pharmaceutical operations into decentralized cost and profit centres. Teva proposed a transfer pricing system based on marginal costs. But the proposed transfer pricing system generated a storm of contro
> The financial mission of a company should be to invest and create cash flows in excess of the cost of capital. If an investment is announced that is expected to earn in excess of the cost of capital, then the value of the firm will immediately rise by th
> From Real World View 19.1, you know that Siemens operates in many countries and has quite a diverse product offering. With such complex and broad operations, there are many factors that can affect the performance of a business sector or division. In its
> German global company Siemens AG had a turnover of almost €76 billion in 2015, recording a profit after taxes of €7.4 billion, according to its annual report. The company operates globally, with 351 000 employees globally. Siemens is a diverse organizati
> A distinguishing feature of today’s digital technology is that it is characterized by zero (or near-zero) marginal costs. Once you’ve made the investment needed to create a digital good, it costs next to nothing to roll out and distribute millions of cop
> In a BBC documentary called Power to the People, Michael Portillo visited a ‘You Decide’ session organized by the local council in Tower Hamlets, London. At this session, local people decide what is to be done with £250 000 of council money. They are giv
> Meditech South Africa (Pty) Ltd provides software solutions to meet the information needs of healthcare organizations in Africa and the Middle East. According to their website, the software can encompass all areas of healthcare from doctor’s offices to h
> Setting standards in an organization may be primarily to assist in the calculation of a standard cost for the product or service for management accounting purposes. Standards are also relevant for operational and customer service managers as they may aff